I work pretty close to a Steak ‘n Shake. I also think their shakes are delicious. Sometimes on slow afternoons, I’ll go buy one and drink (eat?) it. Submitted without further ado, a recent exchange with a friend of mine via IM*:
Me: I think I’m going to get a milkshake
Him: Steak n Shake?
Me: Yeah
Him: Oooh, you gonna go for the super caramel-bomb side-by-side turtle chocolate explosion shake?
Me: No, probably just a vanilla shake.
Him: C’mon, man, if you’re going to indulge like that, you gotta go all out.
Me: It’s not an indulgence, it’s just a milkshake
Him: I hate you.
The more people I speak with, the more I understand I am in the minority when it comes to this kind of thinking. And more and more I wonder why. Why do we view the things we’re “not supposed to have” as indulgences? Why do we deny ourselves so long that when we finally give in to temptation, we completely bust the bank?
If you make a choice about healthy eating, it should not mean you take on some kind of monastic path of self-denial. Far from it. I think you just need to be a little more mindful about the choices you make. Having a milkshake? Why go for the large? Why go for the small? Ask if they have a kids’ size. Also, why go for the most extreme, highly engineered concoction they offer? You think you have a film crew and something to prove? If you want some chocolate, order a chocolate. If I want my vanilla, I’ll get my vanilla.
The other thing I might advise is that you allocate milkshake time. I’m totally serious about this, though it might sound like a quip on a Dove Promise wrapper: when you’re drinking a milkshake, drink the milkshake. Don’t rush back to the office and feel like you have to suck the damn thing down before you get off the elevator. It’ll make you sick and leave you feeling unsatisfied.
Savor it. Be aware that you’re drinking a milkshake. Rather than beating yourself up over it, embrace it. This is my moment. This is my milkshake. Consider each sip. Again, this sounds like some kind of feel-good bullshit designed for a 40ish woman newly divorced and considering a third cat, but it’s also rooted in some serious science: eating more slowly leaves a person feeling more sated. It allows his body to keep pace with his mouth. It enables you to be conscious of your behavior.
Awareness is key. If you’re aware of your milkshake today, you’re less likely to have one by accident tomorrow. And becoming more aware of your food and eating will make you less likely to reach for that fifth handful of M&M’s. Moving the dish from desk will help that, too. But then, you already knew that.
*I don’t save transcripts of my IM conversations because I’m not desperate or creepy or stalkery. Consider this paraphrased.



